Storefront Notes

Grow your ecommerce store · Conversion · 3 min read

How to Set a Free Shipping Threshold That Pays for Itself

Short answer

Set the threshold a little above your current average order value, often 10% to 30% higher, then check that the gross profit on an order at that size still covers your average shipping cost; test it for a few weeks and keep it only if order value and profit per order rise.

Key takeaways

  • A free shipping threshold works by nudging shoppers to add a little more to their cart.
  • Start from average order value: a threshold far above it is ignored, and one below it gives away shipping on orders that would have happened anyway.
  • Check the math at the threshold: gross profit on an order of that size minus average shipping cost must still leave you a profit.
  • Show progress in the cart and offer low-cost add-on products that close the gap.

Free shipping is one of the few offers shoppers notice before they've even looked at the product. A threshold, such as "free shipping on orders over $60", turns that offer into a reason to add one more item. Set it well and it lifts order value while protecting margin. Set it badly and you either give away shipping for nothing or show a target nobody tries to reach.

How does a free shipping threshold work?

A threshold makes shipping free once the cart reaches a set amount, so shoppers just below it add more to qualify.

Unexpected costs at checkout are among the most common reasons people abandon carts in Baymard Institute's long-running checkout research, and shipping is the usual culprit. A threshold changes the question in the shopper's head from "why is shipping $8?" to "what else could I add for $8?" That's the whole mechanism, and it only works if the gap feels small.

Where should you start?

Start with your average order value over the last 90 days and set the first test threshold 10% to 30% above it.

If your average order is $48, a threshold of $55 to $60 is a sensible first test. Too close to the average, and most orders qualify without anyone changing behavior. Too far above it, and shoppers decide it isn't worth chasing.

Look at the spread of order values too. If most orders cluster around $30 and a few large ones push the average up, base the threshold on the cluster, not the average. Shopify and most platforms can export orders, and a simple chart of order values shows where people naturally stop.

How do you check the threshold is profitable?

Calculate the gross profit on an order at the threshold, subtract the average cost of shipping it, and make sure what's left beats your profit today.

Here's a worked example using round numbers:

Today With $60 threshold
Average order value $48 $58 (target)
Gross margin after product cost 50% 50%
Gross profit per order $24.00 $29.00
Shipping charged to customer $6.00 $0 on qualifying orders
Your shipping cost $7.50 $7.50
Profit after shipping $22.50 $21.50

In this example, the threshold looks worse per order, unless it also raises conversion, which it often does. If 10% more visitors buy, total profit can still rise. That's why the threshold has to be tested, not assumed. Our guide to pricing your product for profit covers the margin side.

Use your real numbers. Include packaging and any carrier surcharges in shipping cost, and remember that heavier qualifying orders may cost more to ship.

How do you test a new threshold?

Run it for at least three to four weeks and compare order value, conversion rate and profit per visitor with the period before.

  1. Write down your baseline: conversion rate, average order value, profit per order and orders per week.
  2. Launch the threshold and announce it on the site.
  3. Avoid running a big sale at the same time, which would muddy the result.
  4. After a few weeks, compare profit per visitor, not just order value.
  5. Adjust in small steps, $5 or so, rather than jumping.

Seasonal swings make simple before-and-after comparisons rough. If your platform supports it, an A/B test splits visitors between thresholds at the same time. Our guide to optimizing your store for conversion covers what else to watch while a test runs.

How do you help shoppers reach it?

Show the remaining amount in the cart and suggest one or two useful, low-cost products that close the gap.

A line such as "You're $7 away from free shipping" works better than a banner on the home page alone. Many cart apps and themes include a progress bar. Pair it with add-ons that make sense: refills, socks, care kits, gift wrap, a smaller size of a bestseller. Avoid filler products that come back as returns.

Also mention the threshold where people decide: product pages, the cart, and your shipping policy page.

What mistakes should you avoid?

The common mistakes are setting the threshold below average order value, ignoring heavy items and changing it too often.

  • A threshold under your current average gives away shipping on orders that would have happened anyway.
  • Large or heavy products can wipe out the margin; exclude them or use a separate shipping profile.
  • International orders usually need their own threshold or no free shipping.
  • Changing the number every week confuses repeat customers and makes results impossible to read.

Review it twice a year or after any change in carrier prices. A threshold that worked when shipping cost $6 may not work when it costs $9.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good free shipping threshold?

There's no universal figure, because it depends on your average order value and margins. A common starting point is 10% to 30% above current average order value, adjusted so the gross profit at that order size covers shipping.

Should I offer free shipping on everything instead?

Free shipping on all orders can work if your prices already include shipping and your products are light. For stores with a wide price range, a threshold protects margin on small orders while still giving most buyers a reason to spend a bit more.

Do free shipping thresholds increase returns?

They can, if people add items just to qualify and send them back later. Watch the return rate for orders just over the threshold, and choose add-on products people actually want to keep.

How do I set a free shipping threshold in Shopify?

In Shopify admin, go to Settings, then Shipping and delivery, open your shipping profile, and add a free rate with a condition based on order price. Exact wording changes over time, so check Shopify's help center if the menus look different.

Sources and further reading

Platform features, prices and policies change. Check the official help pages linked above before you act on a detail that matters to your store.

Related guides