Storefront Notes

Start your online business · Dropshipping & POD · 3 min read

Why Starting a Print-on-Demand Business Might Not Be a Great Idea

By the Storefront Notes Editorial Team · Updated

Short answer

Print-on-demand is easy to start but hard to make profitable. Base product costs are high, so margins are thin after fees and ads; production and shipping are slower than big retailers; quality varies by provider; designs are easily copied; and intellectual property mistakes can get stores shut down. It works best for creators with an existing audience or a strong niche brand.

Print-on-demand (POD) is often pitched as the perfect starter business: upload designs, connect a store, let the supplier print and ship. No inventory, no risk. The setup really is easy. Making money is a different story.

1. Thin margins

POD products cost more than bulk-printed equivalents because each item is made individually. A t-shirt you could screen print in bulk at a low unit cost might cost several times as much through POD before shipping.

Then subtract:

  • Shipping (often charged to you or passed to customers, which hurts conversion)
  • Payment processing
  • Platform fees and apps
  • Marketplace fees if selling on Etsy or Amazon
  • Advertising

The profit left on a typical order can be small, and paid ads can wipe it out. Read how to price your product to run your own numbers.

2. Slower fulfillment

Production plus shipping often takes longer than shoppers expect from big retailers with fast delivery. Delays during busy seasons are common. Slow delivery leads to support tickets, bad reviews and chargebacks.

3. Quality varies

Print quality, garment quality and packaging depend on the provider. With marketplace-style POD networks, providers differ significantly. One bad batch can damage your reputation. Ordering samples helps, but you never fully control production. Compare providers in Printful vs Printify.

4. Designs are easy to copy

Successful designs get copied quickly, sometimes within days, by sellers using the same POD services. Enforcement is slow and often ineffective.

5. Intellectual property risks

Many beginners use trademarked phrases, characters, sports teams or celebrity likenesses. This can lead to takedowns, account suspensions and legal claims. Marketplaces enforce IP rules and remove infringing listings. Only use designs you own or have licensed.

6. Marketing is the real business

With no distinctive product advantage, POD stores depend on marketing. Paid ads are expensive; organic growth takes time. Many POD stores fail not because of products but because nobody finds them.

7. Saturated markets

Generic slogans, popular niches and trending phrases attract thousands of sellers. Standing out requires real creativity or a defined audience.

When POD can work

POD is not a bad model in every situation. It works better when:

  • You have an audience: creators, YouTubers, podcasters, communities or artists who can sell merch directly to fans
  • You have a distinctive design style people seek out
  • You serve a specific niche you understand deeply (see Shopify t-shirt store examples)
  • You use it for testing before ordering bulk inventory
  • You add it to an existing business as extra merchandise

Better alternatives to consider

  • Small-batch bulk printing for proven designs, improving margins and quality
  • Selling digital designs like printables or templates
  • Licensing your art to brands
  • Building an audience first, then launching merch

A quick margin example

Imagine a t-shirt with a POD base cost and shipping that together take a large share of a typical retail price. After payment processing and platform fees, the remaining profit might be only a few dollars per shirt. If you then pay for ads and need several ad clicks to make one sale, that profit can disappear entirely. Run this calculation with your real numbers before launching, and look for ways to raise order value, such as bundles or free shipping thresholds, that make the economics work.

Questions to ask before starting

  1. Who exactly will buy my designs, and how will they find me?
  2. What is my profit per order after all costs and ads?
  3. What makes my designs hard to copy?
  4. Am I sure I have rights to every element of my designs?
  5. Can I accept slower delivery times?

If your answers are strong, POD can be a reasonable low-risk start. If not, rethink. When you are ready to try, see how to start a print-on-demand business and compare with the reasons not to build a dropshipping business.

Frequently asked questions

Can you still make money with print-on-demand?

Yes, but most profitable POD sellers have an audience, a distinctive design style or a niche community, which lowers marketing costs.

What are typical print-on-demand margins?

Margins depend on product, provider and price, but they are usually lower than bulk-printed merchandise because each item is produced individually.

Is print-on-demand better than dropshipping?

POD gives you original designs, which are harder to copy directly than generic dropshipped products. Both share issues like slower shipping and limited control.

Platform features, prices and policies change. Check the official help pages linked above before you act on a detail that matters to your store.

Related guides